Permanenet Residendence Visa In Greenland

Civil Cassation: self-adhesive intervention can propose questions

Supreme Court - Third Civil Chamber, Judgement of 16 October 2008, n.25264

The third involved in a process, where its intervention can be defined as self-adhesive, can submit their own application to the autonomous specification conclusions, subject to the preclusion of evidence. The Supreme Court has reaffirmed its guidance that it had been thwarted by the court on the merits. According to the Supreme Court, in fact, "To argue that the intervening self-adhesive, ie the third party intervenes in the process of other people to rely on a comparison of some of them right on the object or employee entitled raised in the trial stage (first paragraph of Article 105 CCP), may do so until they are not stated conclusions (as Article. cpc 268 first paragraph), but without being able to submit their own independent questions posed by foreclosures for the Arts. 183 and 184 cpc the ability of the original parties to the process of carrying out certain acts (such as that proposed new claims), would in fact nullify any value and usefulness of the case institution of the operations covered in that first paragraph of art. 105 cpc (the primary and litisconsortile), in which fundamental and inescapable is indeed the work of the volunteer assertive intervening to protect their diritti.In other words, it is clear that the regulations that have allowed the aforementioned interventions in the process of the third could be made until the moment of clarification of the conclusions would lose all meaning if it is not logical and legal permitted the same - according to the interpretation of Article. 268 CCP, which contrasts here - the wording of the question, which is the essence intervention concerned. In fact, the term "documents" used by the aforementioned art. 268 certainly the legislature intended to refer exclusively to investigating the intervener should play, as a result of the application proposal, demonstrating the claimed right in the sense that, which took place the final wording of the requests of the original parties to the inquiry process, it remains intervener precluded the possibility of carrying out further investigations and other activities. "There are also no merit to the concerns expressed about the court's unconstitutional reading of the rule set out above," according to the principle that the intervener in the process not può svolgere attività istruttoria preliminare e probatoria che la fase eventualmente avanzata del processo stesso non consenta più alle altre parti originarie e, pertanto, della soggezione del terzo alle preclusioni già formatesi tra le parti in causa, la formulazione della domanda da parte del terzo medesimo non può comportare per definizione alcun ritardo nei termini di decisione della causa stessa o, a maggior ragione, lesione del contraddittorio, dovendo la domanda suddetta essere decisa alla stregua delle prove già acquisite in atti senza poterne espletare altre e svolgendosi comunque l'intervento del terzo in un giudizio in cui le altre parti interessate sono già regolarmente costituite o sono state messe in grado ritualmente di farlo".

Coggins Test Cost Ohio

BONDS IN GENERAL - PAYMENT TO CREDITOR APPARENT - discharge all

Cass. Civ. Section III. - Decision No. 26052 of October 30, 2008

any payment is made in the hands of a creditor apparent effect on release, provided that the debtor has in good faith and without negligence considered the creditor entitled to receive it. The circumstances surrounding the erroneous payment was excusable inferred to be derived from the conduct is particularly dell'accipiens, both the real creditor, and shall be deemed to exist a situation of seemingly excusable in all cases where the two have performed so suggest that each was the representative of the other. Applying this principle, the SC quashed the ruling on the merits, with which it was considered not releasing the payment of that cargo performed by a commercial company in the hands of someone other than the seller (also a commercial company), in a case where the accipiens was found to be the father of members of the selling company, had conducted the negotiations for the conclusion of the deal, he turned to the company selling part of the payments received, and had used the offices of the vendor to send faxes during the negotiations.

My Dog Has New Spots On His Skin

Lack of ATO to determine the rates for the waste disposal service

The Sec. VI of the Tax Commission of Catania declared the nullity of TIA invoices for waste disposal service carried out by ATO sulla base dell'incompetenza di quest'ultime a determinare le tariffe.
Compito che invece spetta inderogabilmente ai Comuni ed in particolare ai Consigli Comunali.
Di seguito la sentenza:

REPUBBLICA ITALIANA
IN NOME DEL POPOLO ITALIANO
LA COMMISSIONE TRIBUTARIA PROVINCIALE DI CATANIA

LA SEZIONE 06 riunita con l'intervento dei Signori:

VITELLIO DOTT. ITALO Presidente
VERGA DOTT. VINCENZO Relatore
RAMPOLLO DOTT. FLAVIO Giudice
Reg. gen. N. 0000/08
Udienza del 30.09.2008 ore 09:00
Sentenza n. 805/6/2008
Pronunciata il 30.09.2008
Depositata in segreteria il 14.10.2008

Con atto depositato il 14.3.2008, CAIO proponeva ricorso avverso la fattura Tia n. 2007 00000000 del 15.11.2007 per euro 271,80, relativa al conguaglio, periodo di riferimento 1.1.2004-31.12.2005, emessa dalla Serit Sicilia Spa per conto dell'ATO CT 3 " Simeto Ambiente S.p.A", riguardante il servizio di raccolta dei rifiuti solidi urbani, chiedendone l'annullamento. A sostegno della domanda il ricorrente deduceva: 1) la nullità degli atti impugnati perché la disciplina generale della T.I.A. non poteva che ascriversi alla competenza del Consiglio Comunale; 2) la violazione dell'ari. 49 del D.Lgs. n. 22/97 e del D.P.R. n. 158/'99; 3) incompetenza istituzionale della Serit. L'ente impositore non si costituiva in giudizio. All'odierna udienza camerale, la Commissione poneva decision in the appeal.

GROUNDS

In the opinion of this Commission must be upheld on appeal, based appalesandosi the main reason for opposition, as this is beyond doubt the powers of the CT 3 "Simeto Spa Environment." the power to determine the level of fee for service.
Indeed, under Article surrichiamato. 49 of Legislative Decree no. 22 / '97, as amended by Law No. 488 / '99 ... costs for services related to solid waste management and waste of any kind or origin lying on the streets and public areas or subject to public use are covered by the municipalities through the establishment of a tariff ... . Composed a portion determined in relation to the essential components of the cost of the service ... and a share compared to the quantity of waste delivered. The rate is determined by local authorities, including in relation to the financial plan of operations for the service.
With this legislative provision, it clearly has been allocated to municipalities a specific function, arguably of a public nature, which addresses specifically the determination of the tariff-related accomplishment of a collective service, according to which the same in the absence of prediction rules, equivalent to that of the source attribution, can not give up through the exercise of power without undermining the legitimacy del proprio operato e di ogni provvedimento consequenziale.
A conferma della giustezza di tale principio va richiamata la giurisprudenza del Consiglio di Stato, secondo cui il potere di delega, in quanto altera l'ordine delle competenze degli organi abilitati ad emettere atti con efficacia esterna stabilite con atto normativo primario o secondario, necessita di un supporto normativo di valore almeno pari a quello attributivo della competenza ordinaria, in quanto diversamente opinando si renderebbe arbitra l'Amministrazione di spostarla caso per caso, e senza alcuna previsione di limiti aggettivi e soggettivi, con l'effetto di privare l'amministrato delle garanzie che sono insite nelle attribuzioni di uno specifico organo. Nel caso in esame, ad avviso di questa Commissione, le delibere commissariali e consiliari sulle quali ATO CT 3 fonda la propria legittimazione ad istituire le tariffe per il servizio, determinandone l'entità, sono da considerarsi illegittime perché adottate in assenza di disposizione di legge che le autorizzassero e devono essere disapplicate a norma dell'art. 5 della legge 20-03-1865 n. 2248, ali. E, secondo cui il giudice è tenuto ad applicare gli atti amministrativi ed i regolamenti generali e locali in quanto siano conformi alle leggi.
Tale convincimento trova conforto nell'impugnazione proposta dal Commissario dello Stato avverso l'art. 11, comma 1°, della legge regionale n. 17 del 2004, che esplicitamente assegnava alle Società d'Ambito la competenza a determinare the disease, on the ground that the provision adopted was incompatible with art. 49, 8 th paragraph, of Legislative Decree no. 22 / '97, which gives local authorities the power to determine fees for this service. Following that appeal, Notis, the regional law that was published in the GURS No 31/12/2004 56 without the rule cited above, pursuant to which, therefore, never entered into vigore.Non is argued that, even if the sentence recently handed down (No. 52 of 2008), the Regional Administrative Court, a branch of Catania, has recognized the competence of the ATO to determine the Company tia
According to the ruling in truth, had taken place actual transfer function with relative change in the ownership of the power that moves by the city, administratively, in the hands of the public body specifically established. The transfer of functions, in the opinion of a branch of Catania in the TAR, it was made legitimate art. 1 b DL 07/02/2003 n. 15 (converted into Law 04/08/2003 n.62), who, to address the unique persistent and urgent need to overcome the environmental emergency, had expressly confirmed the various decrees of the President of the Council of Ministers issued in this regard between the 1999 and 2002, the appointment of the President of the Sicilian Region and the powers delegated to the Commissioner and the skills that OM May 31, 1999 n.2983 del Ministro dell'Interno delegato per il coordinamento della protezione civile, nonché le ordinanze di protezione civile ed i conseguenti provvedimenti emanati in regime commissariale, sul territorio nazionale, inerenti alle situazioni di emergenza ambientale e relativamente allo stato di inquinamento delle risorse idriche nel settore dello smaltimento dei rifiuti solidi urbani, speciali e speciali pericolosi, in materia di bonifica e risanamento ambientale dei suoli, delle falde e dei sedimenti inquinati, nonché in materia di tutela delle acque superficiali e sotterranee e dei cicli di depurazione.
E' stato rilevato nella sentenza che con l'O.M. n. 2983 del 31-05-1999, era stata conferita al Commissario Delegato, ai fini dell'esecuzione del mandato, la potestà di derogare, ove necessario, ad una serie di norme, in esse compreso l'art. 32 della legge 09-06-1990 n. 142, come recepito dalla legge della Regione siciliana 11-12-1991 n. 48, articolo riguardante le competenze dei Consigli comunali, tra le quali rientrava l'istituzione e l'ordinamento dei tributi e la disciplina generale delle tariffe per la fruizione dei beni e dei servizi.
Ad avviso di questa Commissione, però, contrariamente a quanto affermato dal T.A.R., Sezione staccata di Catania, non può fondatamente ritenersi che con l'O.M. suddetta sia stata conferita al Commissario Delegato la potestà di derogare alla competenza dei Consigli comunali in materia di istituzione ed ordinamento dei tributi e di disciplina tariffs for the purchase of goods and services, including art. 32 paragraph 1 letter. g) of the Act cited above. Article. 15 of the aforementioned Ministerial Order, in fact, provides that the Commissioner may delegate to derogate from a set of rules but in accordance with general principles of law. It is certainly not consistent with the principles of the Order who generated the municipal entity to delegate its powers within society on the government of taxes and the regulation of tariffs for the use of goods and services.
can not be considered decisive, the inclusion of Article. 32 in the above-mentioned rules waived pursuant to art. OM No 15 2983 of 1999, as well as the considerations for the fact that Article. 32, beyond the competence of municipal councils in the above-mentioned matters, provides that the same advice for a variety of arts, for which no legal obstacle to prevent the derogation. So it is true that Article. 15 of the Ordinance mentioned above does not include the right to derogate. 49 of Legislative Decree No 22 / '97, according to which the tariff for waste disposal is determined by local authorities.
Nor does recall, as it does in some ways the TAR in the above sentence, the Legislative Decree No 03/04/2006 152 (Environmental Regulations) is not applicable in this case because not yet in force. Article. 238, 6 th paragraph, of Legislative Decree referred to above, in fact, provides that, within six months from the date of entry into force of Part IV of the decree, the Minister for the Environment, in consultation with the Minister of Production Activities, after consulting the Conference of State regions and autonomous provinces of Trento and Bolzano, the qualified representatives of the economic and social interests in the Economic and Social Council for the environmental policies and stakeholders, would be governed by special regulations on the basis of general criteria that define the components of costs and the price is determined. According to the same article, the price would be determined by the scope of authority within three months from the date of entry into force of this Regulation (Article 238, paragraph 3) and until the adoption of the Regulation and to the fulfillment of obligations for implementation of the tariff would continue to apply the discipline regulations.
Furthermore, the thesis adopted by this Commission is reflected in the judgments of the Regional Administrative Court of Sicily, the first section (see the judgments to 2290 / '07e2995 / '07).
With these rulings, the Regional Administrative Court, its specifications, as decided by a branch of Catania, held that, pending the entry into force of the D. Legislative Decree No. 152/2006, the power to determine the fee for the collection and disposal of waste lies with the City Council. To that end the Administrative Court Regional reached the judgments referred to above recital: the legislature, with the art. Paragraph 49 of Legislative Decree No 8 ° 22 / '92, had expressly provided that the tariff was determined by local authorities, that even according to the DPR 158 / '99 "the local authority determines the rate" on the basis of the financial plan, which the opposing argument does not help the reference to the various orders issued by the President of the Region - the Extraordinary waste emergency, which, moreover, the ' No OM 2983 of 05.31.1999 did not attribute to the Extraordinary Commissioner the power to make exceptions to the provision of Article legislation. 49 D. Legislative Decree No. 22 / '97 that the same plan for waste management in Sicily was not useful to opposite approach, providing that "the rate is determined by local authorities and levied and collected by the Public service managers" that the maintenance of the power of setting the tariff on the part of municipal entity, as required by article 49 of D. Legislative Decree No. 22 / '92, did not preclude the organizational function and managers of ATO, which had already been legally recognized if the management company the power to set the tariff, there is no reason why the regional legislature had given, with art. 11, paragraph 1, of the Law reg. No 17 of 2004, the Company's scope of that power, that this rule, however, was challenged by the Commissioner of the State for unconstitutional and was not then published, which had been improperly invoked legislative news in D. Legislative Decree No. 152 / '06, with which it was assigned to Area Authorities, however, different from the previous scope of the Company, the power to determine the tariff, because it still vigore.Le commissarial and Board deliberations on which bases TATE CT 3 His work, therefore, can not be declared unlawful.
The illegality of the orders referred to above, of course, extends to the invoice issue in this case, which therefore must be annulled. Prejudice is, of course, the right to request the ATO CT 3 seat in another jurisdiction and in other respects, the determination and payment of a fee for the service provided.
Regarding costs, the Commission considers, having regard to the nature of the dispute and to the peculiarities of the issues that are justified grounds to fully compensate the parties.

PQM

The Commission accepts the application and award costs.
Decided in Catania on 30.09.2008.

What Is Ventilation Perfusion Mismatch

The existential damage there? The position of the United Sections

Supreme Civil SSUU, Case No. 26972 11.11.2008

In recent years the figure of the damage has written important existential moments, ranging from fertile and barren land, between those for and against, conferences and books, emotions and fears.
In particular, it was doubtful what should be understood by category existential damage, also was not clear whether that figure, even if any, could be combined with the biological damage (as a violation of the right to health, art. 32 Cost .) and non-pecuniary damage (defined traditionally as a transient psychological disturbance).
Finally, with a firm stance, the United Sections argued that the non-pecuniary damage, art. 2059 cc, can not be divided into different items for damages, but must be viewed as essentially unique.
The position of the United Sections Sections
United deal, a professed former, the issue in question.
First, art. 2059 cc to be completed with the structural elements of art. 2043 cc
Then, there are assumptions encoded in non-pecuniary damages in connection with the compromise of personal values \u200b\u200b(Article 2 1. No 117/199), damages resulting from the deprivation of liberty caused by the exercise of judicial functions; Article 29, paragraph 9, 1. No 675/1996; use of illegal procedures in the collection of personal data; art. 44, paragraph 7 of Legislative Decree no. 286/1998, the adoption of acts of discrimination on racial, ethnic or religious art. 2 1. No 89/2001; failure to comply with the reasonable time duration of the process).
Outside of the cases determined by law, by virtue of principle of minimum protection for damages due to inviolable constitutional rights, the protection is extended to cases of non-pecuniary damage produced by lesion of the inviolable rights of the person recognized by the Constitution.
a result of this extension is due in art. Ce 2059, damage from injury inviolable right to health (art. 32 of the Constitution) called biological damage, which is given by the Articles. 138 and 139 of Legislative Decree no. 209/2005, specific legal definition (Judgement No. 15022/2005, No. 23918/2006). Previously, as is known, the protection of biological damage was instead preparing through the bond between the art. 2043 EC and Art. 32 of the Constitution (as held by Constitutional Court. No 184/1986) to avoid the limit imposed by art. Ce 2059, pursuant to which might well have been from the outset to find a place (as held by the subsequent ruling of the Court No 372/1994 for the biological physical or psychological harm suffered by the victim's primary joint).
Find appropriate place in the norm, even the protection afforded to those who have seen the inviolable rights of the affected family (Articles 2, 29 and 30 of the Constitution) (Judgement No. 8827 and No. 8828/2003, concerning the case of damage loss or impairment of the parental relationship in the case of death or cause serious disability of a spouse [1] ).
same happened to it to damage resulting from the invasion of the reputation, image, name, to privacy, the inviolable rights of the person recorded in his dignity, preserved by the Articles. 2:03 GC (Judgement No. 25157/2008).
Outside of these cases, the formulation can obtain compensation for the non-pecuniary damage, but only if it is found that the infringement of a person's inviolable right: there must be an injustice constitutionally qualified [2] . Therefore, not all lessons can be compensated to the person or any non-pecuniary bias, but only those who make unjust constitutionally qualified.
should be abandoned subcategories existential damage [3] and material damage [4] , because you just check the damage to the inviolable rights of the person; also read that the interpreter must follow is that of art. 2059 cc with inviolable constitutional rights, which are not intended as an exhaustive list: the protection is not restricted to cases of inviolable rights of the person expressly recognized by the Constitution in this historical moment, but, by virtue of the opening article. 2 of the Constitution to an evolutionary process, the interpreter must be considered possible to infer from the overall constitutional system indexes that are appropriate to assess whether new emerging interest in social reality are not generally relevant for the sort, but doing is constitutional positions inviolable of human [5] . The CD
existential injury is therefore compensable only to the extent constitutionally qualified marked by the injustice of the event of damage. If there is no infringement of constitutionally inviolable rights of the person is not given compensation claims.
The seriousness of the offense is additional requirement for admission to non-pecuniary damages resulting from the injury to the person's constitutional rights inviolable. The law must be recorded over a certain threshold, causing a serious injury. The injury must exceed a certain threshold of offensiveness, making the injury so serious as to be worthy of protection in a system that imposes a minimum degree of tolerance [6] . The filter
the severity of the injury and the seriousness of the mistake through the balance between the principle of solidarity with the victim, and that of tolerance, with the result that the non-pecuniary damages is payable only if the level is exceeded tolerability and the injury is not futile. Prejudices characterized by futility [7] each person listed in the complex social context must accept them under the duty of toleration requires that cohabitation (Article 2 of the Constitution).
Both requirements must be confirmed by the court according to the parameter constituted by the social consciousness in a particular historical moment.
From the beginning of the necessary recognition to the inviolable rights of the person [8] , the minimum protection consists of the compensation, it follows that the lesion of the inviolable rights of the person who has given a non-pecuniary damage includes the obligation to compensate the damage , whatever the source of liability, contract or tort.
If the breach of the obligation shall, in addition to the breach of the obligations of economic employed under the contract, including the infringement of a person's inviolable right of the creditor, the protection of non-pecuniary damages can be paid in the action of responsibility contract, without recourse to the expedient cumulation of actions. What
non-pecuniary interests may be relevant in the context of contractual obligations, is confirmed by the provision of Article. Ce 1174, according to which the provision was the subject of the obligation must be capable of economic assessment and should correspond to an interest, whether or not capital, of the creditor.
The identification, in relation to the specific case of contract, including interest in the contract that, in addition to those in financial content, present a non-asset, should be conducted to ascertain the cause of the actual shop, to be understood as a synthesis of the real interests that the contract is intended to establish, beyond model, even typical, used, summary, and then concrete reason, the dynamics of contract.
Even in non-pecuniary damage can merge the logical scheme compensation ex art. 1223 cc, so that in this matter must keep in mind is the loss, as the non-utility [9] .
As for the complicated issue of damages thanatological [10] inherent all'irrisarcibilità the damage from instant death, which assumes a weak point in the compensation system (because it threatened to leave no legal protection merely because the victim of is not spent an appreciable period of time between injury and death, reducing considerably the possibilities for compensation), arriving at the solution that is unconstitutional and paradoxical punished more severely aggravated by the injury death compared to the so-called direct and immediate death, the Supreme Court stated that the court may instead recognize and properly settling the only material damage, a refreshment of mental suffering experienced by the victim of physical injury, which is followed shortly thereafter the death, which has been polished during the agony of waiting in conscious end. Is avoided given the lack of protection by the law that denies the legitimacy, in the case of immediate death or damaging event occurred a short distance, damages for loss of biological life and admits to the loss of health only if the individual has been alive for a considerable time, which defines man. One such mental suffering, even if the maximum intensity of life contained, they are not likely, because of the limited time interval between injury and death, to degenerate into disorder and result in biological damage, it should be compensated as moral damages, in its new broadest sense. Reflections
short hot
The joint sections indicate the way forward in the field of personal injury and there is, indeed, a certain openness in favor of the human person and of its dynamic and relational aspects, but it is treated to a new place : it has gone from existential damage, as a category, injustice constitutionally qualified.
There is, necessarily, a deminutio of protection, but a perspective different: there is more than one category, but a series of damages related to injuries of the inviolable rights of the human person, to check and read from time to time, through a combined reading of Article. 2059 cc with Groundnorm.
If, otherwise, had been accepted at the prospect that he wanted to confirm the category of existential damage would run the risk, according to the Court, to bring the art. 2059 cc, which is a typical character, nell'atipicità distinctive art. 2043 cc, id est, the existential damage could not be recognized because not typical, in contrast to the letter of the same Article. Since Article 2059 cc
. 2059 cc is typical, then, can be connected with Article standards (such as the Constitution) and not with the category of existential damage, which did not present the characteristics of the breed.
protection, then it is extended to a creditor injured after a failure because it will also benefit the non-pecuniary damages, through the exaltation of art. 1174 [11] cc (non-pecuniary interest on the CD), without having to act as a tort action in combination with the contract, because we must guarantee at least the remedy in compensation cases of injury of the inviolable rights of the human person (otherwise, there would be a weak point in art. 24 of the Constitution); interesting application of Article. 1223 [12] cc to non-pecuniary damage, with the result that should be compensated not only the loss but also loss of earnings: in the event of biological damage, for example, you should not consider only the loss of a part of the body, but also lost profits arising from such loss (forced renunciations to be with their children, play with them or stay with his wife, driving, etc..), as long as identified in the Constitution, accepting too extensive argument for on the general clause of Article. 2 of the Constitution

Russian Bare Fotos Gratis

DAMAGES - INJURY FUTURE - permanent consequences FOLLOW ROAD TO LEFT - CHILD ACTIVITIES NOT ENGAGED IN 'WORK - CIVIL SETTLEMENT PROCESS-

JUDGEMENT NO 24331 30/09/2008 THE

The Third Civil Chamber, ruling on compulsory insurance against civil liability arising from the use of vehicles and boats, has established and perfected a principle which was introduced by Sec. III, No. 23298, 14.12.2004, on the theme of the commensurate to the damage resulting child is not engaged in paid work. In that regard, said that when this child suffers as a result of a traffic accident, personal injury, with permanent consequences, impact on future earning capacity, its damage to be compensated - a significant gain in the least perceive that the child than he would have received if his earning capacity was not impaired - may be determined pursuant to Art. 1226 cc depending on the type of activity that presumably exert a minor, according to probabilistic criteria, taking account of the studies undertaken and inclinations expressed by the minor himself, as well as the socio-economic position of the family. If the trial court does not wish to use this presumptive evidence, may have recourse, on an equitable basis, the criterion of three times the social pension. The choice between one or the other, on the merits, is final within the legitimacy, if suitably motivated. In the same pronunciation is found also said, according to RV. 600,386, the insurer, in Following the request of the victim made pursuant to Art. 22 of Law No 990 of 1969, is obliged to fulfill directly towards the victim that the debt of compensation arising from the insurance contract and that, after the expiration of the sixty days provided by that rule, he is in arrears to the victim, if was placed in a position to be determined in order to '"an" and the "quantum" of liability. In this case, the insurer's obligation to the victim may exceed the ceiling for improper delay (for "maladministration" so-called improper) as a liability for the failure of a debt and, therefore, without proof of damage, the interest earned on the ceiling for the time of arrears and the legal rate, and beyond this level in the presence of allegation and evidence (including by presumptions) of a greater harm.

Cover Letter For Dentist Receptionist

INABILITY' A WITNESS

JUDGEMENT NO 10744 24/04/2008 THE

spouses in joint estate of the goods is unable to testify in cases involving the question of payment for the provision of non-business operates, the proceeds of which fall immediately in communion (Case No. 10398 ), while it is unable to testify in cases involving the payment of the provision of an entrepreneurial nature, because the claims arising from the become common only at the time of the dissolution of the communion (Case No. 10,744).